
Originally Posted by
FlynnFish
in this case I don't see that it takes 2-3 years to get a functional female. Perhaps it may be different depending on the species or maybe I'm just special, LOL.
Um, you nailed it - "species" matters. Ocellaris generally has a maturity time of 1 to 1.5 years for a female, but it seems that Percula are generally closer to 3, and "Black Ocellaris" 3-4 years for some (unless you "cook" them with uber-high temps, which in essence speeds up EVERYTHING, including metabolism but also aging).
And no, you have a better chance at "finding" a mate if you remain male. The logic is simple. As a "male", you can take either role in a new pairing. If you are smaller/subordinate in the new pairing, you can remain male. If you are larger/dominant in the new pairing, you can turn female. If you are female, the ONLY acceptable mate that can be offered is a male. To the best of my recollection, there is only one documented case of a known "female" clownfish reverting to a functional male. I don't like those "odds". In bidirectional hermaphrodites, those that can "revert", i..e
Pseudochromis cyanotaenia, it was Wittenrich that noted that it can take longer (i.e. perhaps twice as long) to "revert" to the earlier initial sex, than to go from the initial to the final sex. In laymans terms, if a clownfish was mature enough to become a female, it could do so in lets's say hypothetically 1 month. But if that female were to then meet up with another female, and on the outside chance that it even COULD revert to being male, in theory, it could take significantly longer (a hypothetical 2 months for example) to revert (again, assuming that clownfish even could at any point). Bottom line, staying male leaves both sides of the coin open. Turning female reduces your chances of finding a mate.
Of course,given that the "female" is going to be the older, dominant fish, it is far more likely that if you're a single fish in an anemone, any newcomer is going to likely be a smaller, younger fish, who is in need of a home. So it's my guess that in the wild, "staying male" when a female dies won't "double" your odds of finding a mate parsay, because while you can mate with 100% of potential new arrivals, the truth is that a Female might be able to mate with 80-90% of new arrivals as well, simply because any new arrival to an anemone is far more likely to be a juvenile / young fish, and not some older, wandering female who's suddenly looking for a new home. In the end though, staying male means = a 100% match should any suitable new clownfish come along.